I Really Hope I’m Wrong Here.
Really, really, really.
News accounts a couple days ago of the latest sniper attack, at the Home Depot in Falls Church said there were witnesses who provided key details to police about the shooting, as one of them actually saw the guy shoot. The witnesses told police the shooter used an AK-74 assault rifle and said the driver of the getaway van was of Middle Eastern descent.
Now police are saying one of the witnesses filed a false report, there's no reason to think the sniper's Middle Eastern or using a terrorist weapon, and according to Stephen Manning of the Associated Press they’re contemplating filing charges against the guy.
Of the hundreds and hundreds of tips, leads and other calls to police, none of which have panned out, this is the first time I’ve heard of cops considering punishing a guy for coming forward with something.
It’s also the first time I’ve heard the suspect described as “Middle Eastern.”
On the whole I trust the cops here, they want to get this guy as much as the public wants them to get him. There are over 200 detectives working the case. Cops from neighboring jurisdictions are being pulled in to help, they’re getting literally hundreds of tips and calls from people who think they’ve seen or heard something – the vast majority of it worthless, but still it’s better than no help at all.
So why is this one guy who was at the scene of the latest attack being singled out for possible punishment? Because he claimed the suspect was Middle Eastern, and that’s not what anybody wants to hear right now?
I really, really hope I’m wrong about that. I’d love to be proven wrong.
Let’s recap.
Sniper shoots and kills a woman in a Fairfax County Home Depot parking lot Monday. Witnesses around. One comes forward and tells cops he got “a good look” at the guy in the white van. “That incident initially appeared to give police a big break in the case — the first witness to actually see the sniper,” one news report said.
According to Allen Breed of the Associated Press “Robert Young, a Washington construction worker, was among witnesses to Monday night’s shooting who returned to the shopping center Tuesday to talk with police.
“He said he heard a muffled gunshot and saw a white van. Young said as he backed his truck out of his parking spot, a white Astro van with two men inside tried to turn into his lane. He said the driver appeared very agitated to find his way blocked and instead drove by a neighboring restaurant and out of sight.
“Young described the driver as a short man of slight build who appeared to be Middle Eastern. ‘I got a good look at the guy,’ he said.
“The driver ‘seemed to be excessively irritated because he couldn’t pull into my lane,” Young said. ‘I thought this fool was going to want to get out of the van and duke (fight) or something. But he didn’t. He kept on going.’”
Young probably isn't the one who’s under suspicion of filing a false report, although Montgomery County Police Chief Charles Moose, according to Manning, “chastised reporters for running reports about the weapon and descriptions of the suspect as olive-skinned, possibly Hispanic or Middle Eastern.” To me that says the witness who reported the guy being olive-skinned is the non-credible one, but I could be wrong.
I thought it strange that cops tried to downplay the sighting almost as soon as it happened. “There are a couple of people who believe they saw a man shoot, unfortunately distance and darkness and perhaps adrenaline have made them unable to give a clear composite that we can disseminate,” Montgomery County Police Capt. Nancy Demme told Breed.
“Demme said one witness told police the shooter used an AK-74 rifle to kill 47-year-old FBI analyst Linda Franklin on Monday night outside a Falls Church, Virginia, Home Depot store,” Breed writes. “Police said the weapon can fire the .223-caliber round recovered from some of the shooting scenes.
“The witness firmly believes this is the weapon,” Demme said. “But we have to keep in mind that weapons are interchangable, like vehicles.”
What? Nobody else has seen the gun, this guy’s seen it, he “firmly believes” it’s the weapon, it fits with what cops know of the ordnance used and you’re saying it’s probably not the gun? Based on what? Other than the fact that you don’t want the public thinking there’s some Arab with an AK-74 running around shooting people, you’d rather they think it was some good old white American disgruntled postal employee with his huntin’ gun?
Bogus? Why?
As Manning reports “Moose said the witness’ emphatic description of the shooter’s AK-74 assault rifle is also bogus.” Based on what? It can shoot the bullets being dug out of the victims, nobody else has seen the gun, how do you know it’s bogus? If someone “firmly” believes it’s the gun he must know something about guns, he’s seen it and you haven’t, why call his account bogus?
Now, I’m almost completely ignorant of what police know in the case. I haven’t talked to any of the witnesses, I don’t know a thing about this supposedly non-credible witness and his story beyond what I read in the papers, but I do know that the AP’s Manning reports “authorities say they haven’t ruled out the possibility there could be multiple suspects.” And let me repeat that I’d be overjoyed if I were wrong about what I think.
But I wonder a couple things. I wonder why they would pounce on this guy unless they knew for a fact he was trying to screw them up. Isn’t that going to discourage other people who are afraid of being accused of filing a false report for telling cops something they’re pretty sure of but wouldn’t stake their lives on? If you know the guy’s lying to you keep that quiet for now and deal with him later, don’t dampen the enthusiasm of others for coming forward with what they think they know.
Maybe they do know that this guy’s trying to mess with the investigation, in which case kudos to them, they know a whole lot more than they’re letting on. Maybe that’s good police work – I believe it’s fairly common practice for cops to poormouth an investigation just before they’re ready to arrest someone.
Remember those killers who escaped from prison a couple years ago? Authorities were talking about significant leads on one side of the country almost as they were arresting them on the other. That’s good police work, it gives the target a sense of security and keeps him from running, making the cops’ job easier. I’m all for that.
I can’t see how that’s the case here. The reason cops were initially so pumped about this witness is he was the first to
see the sniper. In other words, apart from this guy nobody has a clue whether he’s white, olive-skinned, black or pink with purple polka-dots. And cops say they know this witness, who was about 50 feet from the shooting is wrong, but they don’t say who they think is right.
And I wonder, and this is the part I really hope I’m wrong about, if cops simply don’t want the guy to be Middle Eastern. If politically correct negative profiling – can’t say he’s Middle Eastern, can’t have seen an assault weapon – is going on here.
Even before the witness was branded non-credible, the AP’s Breed wrote “[b]ut the witness reports of the shooter — some of which described the suspect as dark-skinned or Middle Eastern — were not consistent.” “The only common denominator thus far is male,” Demme said. “We don’t have a refined description to go by.”
Glen Guymon told Frank Clines of
The New York Times that he and the witness in question started talking when police ordered them inside the Home Depot after the shooting. Guymon said the witness told him he saw a man in the parking lot standing behind a cream-colored Chevy Astro van. “There was a woman walking out to her car, he said she was with a guy,” Guymon, who didn’t see the shooting, told Clines. “The guy behind the van lifted up a rifle and shot her, then got in the car and drove off. He was probably about 50 feet away from where he shot her.”
Reached at home Thursday, Guymon told The Associated Press: “I’m shocked [the witness in question] was lying because he had a very detailed story. The guy sounded credible. He didn’t sound like he was making it up.”
Maybe he wasn't. Maybe there are Middle Eastern guys with AK-74 assault rifles running around picking off Americans. And maybe that's not what the cops or anyone else wants to hear.
Boy I hope I'm wrong.